GETAWAYS • Montauk
There are two types of places in Montauk: those that embrace the laid-back nature of a beach town, and those that play into Montauk’s newer notoriety as a party spot. This summer, it felt like the latter were multiplying, but there’s still relatively chill refuge to be found. One of those places is Mostrador at the Marram Hotel.
Set along the Terrace surf break, Mostrador channels the spirit of its South American sister location in José Ignacios, Uruguay. While word has spread about Mostrador’s indulgent and abundant breakfast pastries, I’m here to make a case for lunch, for those lingering out east into the shoulder season.
In the Hamptons, lunch can be an annoying meal to plan, especially if, like me, you filter based on: “Where can I get a great meal barefoot and in a wet bathing suit?” Mostrador makes it through that narrow filter.
Lunch service begins promptly at noon, and is ordered to-go style from the counter. Typically, there’s a choice of two or three proteins (I recommend the tender braised chicken if it’s available), alongside an array of beautifully presented vegetable sides.
Each dish is like its own color study of vibrant local produce, punctuated with grains, garnished with fresh herbs, and topped off with a deliciously bright sauce. Portions are generous, and flavors are balanced. You can peek into the modest kitchen while you wait. The Mostrador plate, which includes one protein and three sides, is $49, but is generous enough to share, and they’ll happily split one plate into two, making it even easier.
Take your plate to one of the ocean-facing benches or tables, and watch the surfers battle it out on the break as summer gives way to fall. –Sarah Jackson
→ Mostrador @ Marram (Montauk) • 21 Oceanview Terr • Daily 8a-9p, lunch 12-330p; schedule changes 9/15, closes for season 10/13/25.